Recently a group of NetApp managers tried to motivate their employees by betting that the team could meet a particular project milestone. If the team missed the date, the managers promised to dye their hair bright colors. (Silly hair bets have a long history at NetApp.)
Unfortunately, the team missed the date, and as a result, the managers not only had to deal with bad news, but they had brightly colored hair to advertise it. When people would ask, “What happened to your hair,” the managers had to say, “I bet my team that they would hit their schedule, but they missed.”
Even if there are perfectly good reasons for the miss, the listener might still conclude: You not only look like a clown, but you manage a whole team of clowns.
Much better to bet that your team will fail. When I first started running engineering (back in 1999), product reliability was an issue, so I bet my employees that they could not improve quality by a factor of 10. If they did, I would dye my hair any color that they wanted.
Imagine how this played out. The team succeeded (as measured by a man who cared so deeply about quality that I knew he would never cheat), and I ended up with hair that was bright magenta, blue, and red. To get hair these colors you can't put it on top of brown; you have to start by bleaching to white. So I looked like a freak, but at least, when people asked me about it, I had a good answer: “Let me tell you about my awesome team. I should never have bet against them.”
The conclusion: You
look like a clown, but at least you manage a good team.
So I say, always bet against your employees. Of course, it helps if they understand it’s a bet you want to lose.